Where EAST meets the Northwest
ROLLER-COASTER SEASONS. This season has been a roller-coaster ride for
Asian-American college football fans. Ken Niumatalolo, the first Samoan coach
ever in Division I football, rebounded from a disappointing year to lead Navy to
a record-setting season. But an injury derailed another epic year by Tua
Tagovailoa, Alabama’s fantastically talented Asian-American quarterback.
Ken Niumatalolo. (AP Photo/Julio Cortez)
Tua Tagovailoa. (AP Photo/Vasha Hunt)
From The Asian Reporter, V30, #01 (January 6, 2020), page 10.
Asian-American triumph and tragedy in college football
By Mike Street
Special to The Asian Reporter
This season has been a roller-coaster ride for Asian-American college
football fans. Ken Niumatalolo, the first Samoan coach ever in Division I
football, rebounded from a disappointing year to lead Navy to a record-setting
season. But an injury derailed another epic year by Tua Tagovailoa, Alabama’s
fantastically talented Asian-American quarterback. Both stories show sports at
its best and most frustrating, while underscoring the huge strides made by
Asian-American athletes in recent years.
Samoan-American Niumatalolo has been shattering barriers since 2007, when he
was named the head coach of the Navy Midshipmen football team. Now the
winningest coach in Navy history, he has led the team to a 98-59 record in 12
seasons, 10 of them winning seasons that featured bowl game appearances.
In 2011, his first losing season, the team finished 5-7 — not a terrible
performance, and at least they beat rival Army. But last season was truly
dismal, as the team staggered to a 3-10 record, suddenly unable to win,
especially against rival Army, who beat them for the third straight year.
Niumatalolo made some tough choices before this season, from hiring
nutritionists to letting go of his defensive coordinator. Most importantly,
however, he committed to making Malcolm Perry his starting quarterback. "I told
Malcolm, ‘We’re giving you the keys; it’s your team,’" Niumatalolo explained
about the change.
Always a good runner, Perry received special coaching on his passing. The
skill and confidence derived from Niumatalolo’s decision paid massive dividends
this year, as Perry has blossomed into one of the most dynamic forces on the
A true double threat in Navy’s triple-option offense, Perry set Navy
single-season records for running yards and total yards, part of the team’s best
rushing season ever. He also set the Football Bowl Subdivision (FBS) record for
rushing by a quarterback, with 2,017 yards on 295 carries, a mind-blowing 6.8
yards per carry. With his arm, he threw for 1,084 yards and seven touchdowns, an
effective complement to his explosive running ability.
This combination earned him Offensive Player of the Year honors from both the
Eastern College Athletic Conference and American Athletic Conference.
Niumatalolo was awarded Coach of the Year from both conferences, thanks to
Navy’s amazing 10-2 regular season, a huge turnaround from last year.
Both Niumatalolo and Perry were essential against the Kansas State Wildcats
in the AutoZone Liberty Bowl. The nail-biting outcome hinged on two great calls
by Niumatalolo and another dominant performance by Perry, who ran for 213 yards
on 28 carries, throwing for 57 yards and one touchdown.
But Niumatalolo’s strategy really made the difference. With Navy trailing
early 3-7 inside the Wildcats’ 30-yard line, the coach unexpectedly called on
his quarterback’s arm. Perry threw to Hawaiian slotback Keoni-Kordell Makekau in
double coverage for a 27-yard touchdown that gave Navy a three-point lead.
The teams continued to battle throughout the second half until Niumatalolo’s
second crucial call. With time winding down and the score tied 17-17, Navy faced
a fourth-and-three on the Wildcats’ 46-yard line. With everyone expecting Perry
to take the ball for a short gain, Niumatalolo made another great play call.
Perry took the handoff and pitched it to his fullback, C.J. Williams, who
pulled back and looped a perfect deep pass to wide receiver Chance Warren.
Warren was tackled on the five-yard line, then kicker Bijan Nichols stepped in
to nail the game-winning chip shot. It was a true team effort from Niumatalolo
and his star quarterback.
As good as Perry has been, his career has paled against that of Tagovailoa,
Alabama’s star Samoan quarterback. As a 19-year-old freshman, Tua entered the
second half of the 2018 National Championship game against Georgia with his team
down 0-13. Tua engineered an incredible overtime comeback victory to give
Alabama the championship.
Last season, Tua was named the starter as a sophomore, and he responded with
a phenomenal year. He completed 69 percent of his passes for 3,966 yards while
scoring 43 touchdowns against just six interceptions. Oklahoma’s Kyler Murray,
at the helm of a more pass-oriented offense, edged Tua for the Heisman that
year. Even worse, Alabama was unable to repeat as champions, falling 16-44 in
the National Championship against the same Clemson team they’d defeated the year
Energized and ready to regain the national title, Tua started 2019 with six
straight wins, throwing 27 touchdowns and just two interceptions and leading the
FBS with a 95.6 quarterback rating. Then, in his seventh game, he sustained what
seemed to be a season-ending ankle injury.
Instead, he underwent a radical surgery that allowed him to return just two
weeks later, against top-ranked Louisiana State University. Alabama lost
narrowly, 41-46 though Tua had an incredible game on his recently repaired
ankle, throwing for 418 yards and four touchdowns with one interception.
A disappointed Alabama looked to rebound in its next game against the
unranked Mississippi State Bulldogs. The team quickly gained a 35-7 advantage,
with Tua engineering touchdowns on each of the team’s first five drives. Despite
the lead, Alabama coach Nick Saban left Tua to finish the final drive of the
It would prove to be a fateful decision for both Alabama and Tua. On a pass
play, the Bulldog defense sacked for a loss, dislocating Tua’s hip, a painful
injury that knocked him out for the season and possibly threaten his career.
After the injury, Saban said Tua was the only Alabama player who’d been
projected to be a top 15 NFL draft pick. Many were saying he could be the first
overall pick, but such a significant injury has changed that completely. Tua is
expected to announce on January 6 whether he will enter the draft or return to
Alabama for his final year of eligibility, to prove his health and perhaps win
another national championship.
Whether, and where, Tua sets foot on the gridiron again, it will be a
testament to his courage and resilience. For inspiration, he doesn’t need to
look any further than Niumatalolo and his star quarterback, who bounced back
from a terrible year to have a season for the ages.
The fact that Asian-American sports fans have so much to pay attention to
shows how far Asian-American athletes have come in college football, where it’s
no longer unusual to see Samoans behind center or in the front office. We’ve got
a lot to look forward to in 2020 and beyond.
Read the current issue of The Asian Reporter in its entirety!
Go to <www.asianreporter.com/completepaper.htm>!